AI News Feed
Market watch
World

BBC Urges Florida Court to Toss Trump's $10B VPN-Based Defamation Suit

The BBC filed to dismiss Trump's $10 billion defamation suit, arguing that 10 VPN users bypassing geo-blocks cannot establish jurisdiction in Florida.

The lawsuit stems from a 2024 documentary about Trump’s reelection campaign, which he alleges was maliciously edited to make it appear he was inciting violence by combining phrases spoken nearly 55 minutes apart. The BBC later apologized and pulled the documentary from its streaming platforms, but it continues to fight the defamation claim and the enormous damages sought.

Trump’s legal team contends that Florida jurisdiction is proper because the documentary was played 34 times in the state. However, those alleged plays were initiated by just 10 users who used VPNs to circumvent the BBC’s strict geo-blocking. In its motion, the BBC noted that the 34 streams represent just 0.006% of the 570,000 successful requests for the documentary, and characterized them as unconfirmed and completely unauthorized.

The broadcaster argued that the unilateral activity of a third party cannot satisfy the requirement of contact with the forum state, quoting legal precedent. It also said no court has ever established jurisdiction based on a user forcibly bypassing geographical restrictions with a VPN. The BBC uses third-party cybersecurity services such as GeoGuard to detect and block VPN and proxy users, and its Terms of Use strictly prohibit circumvention.

The BBC warned the judge that validating Trump’s legal strategy would have massive implications for foreign companies with online presences. If a user bypassing a digital fence is enough to establish jurisdiction, foreign media companies could be forced to cut off international access or invest heavily in draconian geo-blocking technology to avoid billion-dollar lawsuits in jurisdictions where their content was never officially offered.

Trump is seeking $5 billion for defamation and another $5 billion under Florida’s Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act, according to TheWrap. The wider case also involves fights over executive privilege and subpoenas targeting Donald Trump Jr. and Ivanka Trump, but the immediate hurdle for the plaintiff is proving that the 10 VPN users legally brought the BBC onto Florida soil.

The judge has yet to rule on the motion to dismiss. Unless the case is thrown out based on the BBC’s VPN arguments, the defamation suit is scheduled for a two-week trial in February 2027.