KDE Shelves Draft Rules on LLM-Assisted Code After Thread Derailed; GNOME Developer Proposes a Ban
KDE withdrew a draft policy on LLM-assisted contributions after the discussion was derailed by people largely outside the project, while a GNOME developer proposed barring LLM-written code.
The thread followed KDE's annual Akademy conference last weekend, which included a presentation proposing an "AI-native KDE," The Register reported. KDE developer Nate Graham opened a discussion on proposed restrictions for LLM-assisted contributions; the thread "rapidly became heated," and moderators issued warnings, restricted further comments and eventually removed it.
Writing on his blog, Graham said "a bunch of people mostly outside of KDE who disapprove of LLM usage derailed KDE's attempt to add restrictions to LLM usage." Two people unknown to any KDE contributors, he wrote, appeared and began arguing with each other about the broader morality of AI rather than the proposed guidelines. Someone outside KDE set up kdeforpeople.com to pressure the project into banning LLMs, he added, and while many people signed on, almost none were known KDE contributors. The topic was then picked up on social media and in the press "with varying levels of accuracy," after which the draft proposal was removed and the whole subject hidden.
Graham said the "lovable, sovereign, AI-native KDE" idea was presented by two people who were important to KDE in decades past but had not contributed recently apart from the Akademy talk, and that it does not reflect the overall direction of KDE or Plasma, which he does not expect to change. He wrote that it is completely reasonable and safe to ignore the idea if it alarms people. He also said he understands why many people object to LLMs and shares those concerns, and asked them not to derail future work on usage guidelines by fighting over the general topic of AI. The Register put it as: "The discussion is gone, but the argument continues."
GNOME developer Jordan Petridis has published "The GNOME LLM Policy That I Want," proposing that LLMs be barred from creating or modifying anything submitted to GNOME or hosted on its infrastructure. "You might be asked to prove your code meets this requirement," Petridis wrote, arguing for proposals that target the norms around developer behavior. His stated rationale is that "the GNOME Project prioritizes the social and human aspects of collective software creation."